We had it right

We Had It Right


Seriously, we were kickin' ass!

Let’s revisit America during the middle of the 20th century – roughly the period between the mid-1950s and the early-1970s. Americans had spent the last 200 years pulling themselves up by their bootstraps. They toiled through our colonial period, labored through two industrial revolutions, fought their way out of slavery, evolved from child labor, and crawled back from the Great Depression. By the early 1970s, the average American had some serious mojo, with the working class growing in size, wealth, and influence. In fact, our wealth was growing at about the same rate, if not slightly better, as that of the wealthiest of our fellow citizens.

America had it rightEducation at all levels was improving and becoming more available. People were using their education to innovate, get better jobs, start businesses, and make more money – money that they pumped right back into the economy. All of this created more job opportunities and more economic mobility for everyone – not just the educated.

Money trickled up to the wealthy who were also enjoying the benefits of a financially stronger population of consumers – folks were steadily buying up houses, cars, appliances, an plenty of things they didn’t need. Businessmen, in turn, created jobs to meet that glorious demand.

Meanwhile, our government was responding to the needs of the people. It was taking action to empower them to be more successful and contribute to the advancement of our society. The government also became more “hands-on” and took action to improve our culture and environment, providing a world in which we could thrive. Here are some highlights…

  • The Civil Rights Act of 1964
  • Elementary and Secondary Education Act 1965
  • The Endangered Species Act of 1966 (along with 2 expansions within 7 years)
  • Environmental Protection Agency established in 1970
  • Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) Standards of 1970
  • The Clean Air Act of 1970
  • The Consumer Safety Act (CPSA) 1972
  • Clean Water Act 1972
  • Approval of the Equal Rights Amendment in 1972
  • Comprehensive Environmental Response, Compensation, and Liability Act of 1980 (Think Superfund Sites)

Keep in mind that much of the above was going on just after coming out of the Korean War, still living under the shadow of “Duck and Cover” and nuclear annihilation, and then contending with segregation, race riots, the Vietnam War and its protests, multiple assassinations, and even hippies. It was hardly perfect, but America plowed through all of this because of a strong working class and a government that was becoming more engaged (sometimes begrudgingly, but that’s how governments can be).

We were working hard, playing hard, increasing our trust of each other, and looking at a better future for our kids.

Considering the strengthening working class and their effective government in those days, it’s hard not to notice how things have somehow completely flipped around over the past 50 years. Back then, it seemed as if Democracy was just getting its stride and evolving into what our founding fathers had envisioned. We were working hard, playing hard, increasing our trust in each other, and seeing a better future for our kids. We had the feeling that America was “figured out” and on autopilot. More importantly, we had the sense that we were all in it together. The growing economic ability and mobility of more and more people, enabled by an engaged government, was nirvana for both capitalism and Democracy.

Fast forwarding to now, many of us are at, or below, the poverty level, the middle class is shrinking fast, and “somehow” most of our wealth has been shifted into the hands of only a few of us.  

What went haywire over the past 50+ years? What happened to our momentum? How did the natural evolution of Democracy, speeding forward like a freight train conducted by its citizens, slow to a stop and then reverse direction? 

It was as if someone started to slowly and gently apply the brakes in a way that we wouldn’t notice… until it was too late. Let’s take a look at some graphs that show the results of whatever the hell happened. The first is a YouTube video showing how bad it was back in 2013. It is animated, well-presented, and very much worth a look.

Please take a moment to watch it…

Below is a comparison between 1963 and 2022 – both graphs are in 2022 dollars. One quick look at the two graphs and you can tell how badly we were screwed – the fruit of our decades of hard work went to a very small number of people.  Are we to believe that the spike on the right side resulted from a small number of us suddenly working harder and becoming smarter while the rest of us become stupid and lazy? This is what “trickle-down” looks like.

1963

2022

Source: Urban Institute calculations from the Survey of Financial Characteristics of Consumers 1962, the Survey of Changes in Family Finances 1963, and the Survey of Consumer Finances 1983–2022. Both graphs show wealth in terms of 2022 dollars

Somehow, a country that appeared to be finally living up to being “a more perfect union” that was “of, by, and for the people”, began to leave the people behind. Was this reversal of fortune of the working class caused by the natural evolution of Democracy and capitalism? Or was it something more sinister? If the latter, then who wrestled the money out of the hands of the working class without us even noticing? Who repurposed our government to serve only a few and how did they do it?

It’s not just our money, we’ve also lost power – almost all of it, now. We’ve come a long way from the Boston Tea Party, which was not about new taxes, but about the colonists being forced to accept the British East India Company’s monopoly on tea, control over trade, undermining of local merchants, and influence over government policies. Somehow that script was flipped and we now have a King and corporations, the wealthy, and even foreign actors controlling our government.

Our minds have little chance against cable news, social media, influencers, profiling, algorithms, and the dark money that optimizes and finances it.

This didn’t happen overnight – we would not have allowed it. This was a strategic, stealthy dismantling that unfolded over decades, flying under the radar of most Americans. Once they persuaded the Supreme Court to declare “money equals speech” and “organizations had the freedom of speech”, they could start their attack. They could now use their unlimited and untraceable funds to bribe, lobby, and even threaten our elected officials.

They attack us as well, bombarding us with continual disinformation and propaganda. Our minds have little chance against deceitful cable news, social media and its influencers, behavior profiling, algorithms, and the dark money that optimizes and finances all of it.

They study us like lab rats, learning how to tug on our heartstrings and use our patriotism and vulnerabilities against us. They see us as disposable tools that they befriend and manipulate to get their way, only to toss us out of their limos when they are done with us.

They’ve convinced us that our government is bad, our neighbors are dangerous, helping people is socialism, and helping the wealthy and corporations is patriotic. They’ve become so good at it that many of us now embrace their destruction of everything we once held dear. 

They used the money they stole from us to empower themselves, undermine our democracy, and manipulate us. Our democracy has become a playpen for the wealthy to play in, tossing us around like ragdolls. 

Their devotion to America is only about squeezing all they can out of it – regardless of the trainwreck they leave behind.  They’ve ripped away America’s purpose, direction, integrity, and world standing.

We had it right.  America had it right.  They, the American oligarchs broke it.